Rachie3879’s #CBR5 review #5 The Paris Wife by Paula McLain


Paula McLain’s “The Paris Wife” tells the story of Hadley Richardson and Ernest Hemingway: their whirlwind courtship, marriage, and eventual divorce in the mid-1920s. Hadley is what some of her time would consider a spinster; she’s 28, lives with her sister and brother-in-law, and spends her time practicing the piano and having a few uninspiring beaux. That is till she begins visiting her childhood friend Kate for the summers and is introduced to a young Ernest Hemingway. Ernest is a handsome, vibrant young soldier just back from the horrors of World War I. The pair fall in love and after a short time are married. Ernest’s desire to begin his career as a writer takes the couple to Paris, where they will meet and mingle with some of the most famous literary minds of their generation – Gertrude Stein, Ezra Pound, and F. Scott Fitzgerald. It is in Paris and on trips throughout Europe that Ernest gets the ideas for “The Sun Also Rises.” Though the novel receives enthusiastic reviews, the Hemingways must deal with the trials of a young marriage, parenthood, and finally getting what they’ve always wanted.

It may surprise people to know that though I earned my BA in English and consider myself an avid reader, I cannot recollect ever having read a single Hemingway piece. I wouldn’t swear to it – I may have come across a short story here and there, perhaps during my junior year in high school when English covered American literature – but I may as well not have, since I don’t remember anything. I have always been afraid to read Hemingway; for some reason he’s been lumped for ages in my head with Faulkner, whose writing I cannot stomach. Reading “The Paris Wife” (though fictional) has made me more interested in his writing – it made me realize that perhaps Hemingway isn’t so bad after all (as a writer) and perhaps I should give him a try.

My late-blooming interest in Hemingway really isn’t that interesting to someone wanting to know the merits of this novel about his first wife, so I’ll get going on that pronto! I really enjoyed this book. I usually like historical fiction, so it’s not that surprising I feel this way. History was my second favorite subject in school, so combining it with literature is a big bonus for me. The descriptions of Hadley and Ernest’s life in Jazz Age Paris are so vivid; they begin in Montparnesse and live above a dance hall, listening to accordion music into the wee hours of the morning. Trips to Spain for bullfighting and Switzerland for Alpine skiing really jump out of the text. The story is slow to start at first, but once it got going I found it difficult to put down.

Hadley is an incredibly sympathetic character. Her struggles with self-confidence endeared her to me from the outset; what woman hasn’t worried her clothes weren’t fashionable, her legs weren’t slim enough? She has fallen in love with the type of person who always needs to be the center of attention, who struggles with paralyzing depression. Her life with Ernest was never going to be normal or easy and she came into the marriage only having glimpsed a little bit of this. Hadley is the kind of woman that though part of you wants to scream “LEAVE HIM FOR GOD’S SAKE!!!” to her, the other part of you just wants to hug her for being able to handle such a partner with the grace with which she did. Their marriage didn’t last (sorry, historical figures don’t really get spoiler alerts), but the novel almost makes you feel like they were so perfect for each other for a small part of each others lives.

One thing I didn’t really get was the occasional chapters in italics. For the most part the novel is all about Hadley. We hear almost everything from her point of view and in her words, so to speak. Peppered throughout the novel are some chapters in italics, which for the most part seem to be coming from Ernest’s point of view. I understand that perhaps the writer felt some things needed to be shown that Hadley would have had no way of knowing, but I felt like it takes the reader out of the story. Overall, the read was pleasing, fast, and has engendered in me a curiosity about one of the most famous American authors and ALL his wives. Check it out!

One thought on “Rachie3879’s #CBR5 review #5 The Paris Wife by Paula McLain

  1. Stylistically, Hemingway is very different to Faulkner. Give A Moveable Feast (which is very selective with the facts, and should be read as more of a novel) or The Sun Also Rises a whirl.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s