ABR’s #CBR5 Review #7: The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

gatsbySomehow I made it to adulthood without reading The Great Gatsby or seeing the 1974 movie. But I wanted to read the book before I saw the latest movie version later this year. While there are elements of the book that will translate to the screen (especially in a Baz Luhrmann film), I was disappointed in the book. I know it’s considered a classic, but overall, it’s not an engaging read.

The plot is straightforward. The narrator, Nick Carraway, is a college graduate and war veteran working in New York City, living in West Egg. His next-door neighbor is a mysterious millionaire named Jay Gatsby.

Although Gatsby’s past and the source of wealth are unknown, one thing is certain – he throws extravagant parties, attended by anyone and everyone. “People were not invited – they went there. They got into automobiles which bore them out to Long Island, and somehow they ended up at Gatsby’s door. Once there they were introduced by somebody who knew Gatsby, and after that they conducted themselves according to the rules of behavior associated with an amusement park.”

At one of these lavish parties Nick meets Gatsby, and despite his mysterious past, his questionable wealth and his shady business associates – or more likely because of them – Nick develops a fondness for Gatsby.

Unbeknownst to Nick, Gatsby once dated his second cousin Daisy, who is now married to Tom Buchanan and living in fashionable East Egg. Tom has cheated on Daisy throughout their marriage. His current mistress, Myrtle Wilson, is married to a witless cuckold, who also happens to be Tom’s mechanic.

When Daisy learns that Nick is Gatsby’s neighbor, she coerces him into organizing a reunion with Gatsby and they soon rekindle their romance. Daisy is intent on flaunting the relationship in front of Tom, and he tolerates it, perhaps as retribution for his infidelity, until one awkward evening. After a night of drinking Tom confronts them. Gatsby and Daisy leave together. As they are racing through town, they pass the home of Myrtle Wilson. She and her husband have also been fighting; Myrtle’s husband George knows she is having an affair, but he doesn’t know it is with Tom. Gatsby and Daisy hit Myrtle as she is running to flag down the car and escape George. In the wake of the accident Tom and Daisy appear to reconcile and leave town. Gatsby reveals his back story to Nick, who encourages Gatsby to leave town as well.

Tom tells George that Gatsby struck his wife, and George assumes Gatsby was her lover. He tracks down Gatsby and kills him. Nick is left to contact Gatsby’s family and plan his funeral. Despite his popularity while alive, Gatsby’s funeral is only attended by three people.

I know The Great Gatsby is widely read and much loved, praised by critics and readers for decades. But to me this is a book whose parts are greater than its sum. The individual characters are interesting, but collectively they are the worst type of clique – selfish, aloof, devoid of sympathy or remorse. Even though Nick is likable and pitiable, he’s impressionable. I wonder why he’s so interested in the ‘in crowd’ even though he recognizes how fake they are. I’m not even sure Fitzgerald liked his characters, especially the women. There is not a single admirable female character in the book. They are either materialistic, androgynous or home wreckers.

Moreover, the love story between Daisy and Gatsby, the quintessential love story that was the impetus for all the events in the book, isn’t convincing. In fact, it’s as impulsive and affected as Daisy’s other whims (including the daughter she completely ignores).

In the end Nick finally realized what we’ve known all along, that Daisy, Tom and Gatsby “were careless people … they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness, or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made.” He acknowledges that the East, with all its “superiority to the bored, sprawling, swollen towns beyond the Ohio” has lost its luster for him.

Ultimately Nick wasn’t profoundly affected by the fateful tale of The Great Gatsby, and neither was I.

2 thoughts on “ABR’s #CBR5 Review #7: The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

  1. “The plot is straightforward.”

    I think the reason a lot of people love this book so much is that they disagree with you on this point. I’ve never been a huge fan of it myself, and I’ve read it a couple of times for school, but on my last read I did pick up a bunch of stuff that was happening under the surface that I hadn’t picked up on previous reads. I think it’s a deceptively complex book, mostly because Nick is such an unreliable narrator, but also because on the surface it is a love story, but really I think it’s about the false image Gatsby has created for himself. The idealized man that doesn’t really exist, who wants someone (Daisy) who also doesn’t really exist. And if you follow that to its logical conclusion, since what Gatsby has created is supposedly ‘The American Dream,’ then The American Dream is also an illusion. Something that we shoot for but that never really existed anywhere but in our imaginations.

    Again, it’s been a while so I don’t remember details, and I still didn’t like it all that much (as you mentioned, the characters are really unlikable), but if you go into it with those two things in mind, it is a bit of a deeper experience. I’ll be interested to see Luhrmann’s film and whether or not he goes for that angle, or just the flashy surface stuff.

    Sorry to bust out my English Lit degree on you! Sometimes I just can’t help myself.

  2. I can’t say I disagree with you at all. But even the nuances felt a little cliched to me. Perhaps I’m a little jaded but I think in its time it was a groundbreaking book and probably a scathing commentary on the time, but its impact has lessened over the years. And I know you’re right – there are many, many, many people who would disagree with me. Thanks for taking the time to read the post and comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s